Cusimano's Pizzeria

4.1 ( 110 reviews )
Checking... 10:00 AM - 08:00 PM See Hours
3670 Lake Rd N, Brockport, NY 14420, United States
+1 585-637-7777

Cusimano's Pizzeria, located at 3670 Lake Rd N, Brockport, NY, has quickly made a name for itself as a standout pizza restaurant. Customers rave about the friendly, professional service and the restaurant’s inviting atmosphere, particularly since the management change that has reportedly enhanced the dining experience. Megan Sorg notes the dedication of the young staff, who take pride in their work, contributing to a family-owned vibe that makes patrons feel at home.

The pizza at Cusimano's is a highlight, with Nick Melvin declaring it the best in the area. Visitors like John Haney praise its flavorful New York-style sauce, likening it to lasagna in taste. Their extensive menu includes items such as perfectly cooked wings and generously portioned stromboli, with Tanna Wright calling it the best she’s ever had. Diners looking for flavorful hot wings will appreciate the recommendations from Melissa Le, who champions the steak and Greek salads alongside the popular pizza offerings.

Whether you're dining in or ordering for delivery, the consistently positive reviews speak volumes about this pizzeria's commitment to quality food and service. It’s a must-try for locals and visitors alike!

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Highlights
    • Fast service
  • Popular for
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Offerings
    • Comfort food
    • Quick bite
  • Dining options
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Dessert
    • Table service
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • Kids' menu
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Parking

Reviews For Cusimano's Pizzeria

Megan Sorg
Jun 20,2025
Great place to get food & great employees. Service has improved since the older manager named Tony no longer works there. The employees are yound but seem to like their job and enjoy being there. It's a family owned business that's doing things the right way with happy employees and good food.
Nick Melvin
Jun 11,2025
Best pizza joint in the area. The pizza and food are amazing also the employees are very professional and seem to enjoy working there highly recommend
John Haney
Jun 8,2025
Ordered the large combo and 2 add on tonight for the first time. I'm visiting from out of town and was recommended to try cusimano's from friends that live in the area. The pizza is delicious. we tried Mike's new York style sauce as was recommended by the staff. It was outstanding. We also ordered a kids' pizza for our son and got the traditional sauce. Our son loved it, and he is a very picky eater. We ordered the wings for one add, and we had them plain with country sweet on the side and also mild. Again, I'm not disappointed. Outstanding cooked perfect and juicy. For our second add-on, we asked for the 10 piece mozzarella sticks. Cooked perfectly and so tasty. The staff was so friendly on the phone and answered all our questions as we told them we were trying them for the first time. We we got there to pick up our food the atmosphere was great. Fast service again friendly. Next time we are in town, this will definitely be our go-to place.
Tanna Wright
May 24,2025
Just had the stromboli and it was by far the BEST I have ever had, not to mention that it was HUGE!!! Truly appreciate the great service and welcoming staff. Wright Income Tax (Brockport, NY)
Melissa Le
Apr 28,2025
If you're looking for hot wings WITH FLAVOR, not just heat, look no further! If you're looking for a fresh salad, i highly recommend the steak salad and the Greek salad wIth either chicken or steak. The Cusimano pizza is amazing and resembles lasagna in flavor. The chocolate frosted brownie is hit or miss, but when they're fresh, they are AMAZING!! I got delivery, so I will adjust the atmosphere stars when I visit in person. The delivery driver was kind, courteous, respectful and timely.
Caroline Thompson
Apr 12,2025
Shout out to cusimanos for delivering to Hamlin beach Campground, on time, and hot. A. Flavor good as always
Sally Newton
Mar 25,2025
Fabulous Pizza and even better subs! They have a ton of variety and never disappoint! Great customer service and always pleasant to deal with. Tuesdays extra large meal deal Is a must !!
Joe Rizzo
Mar 16,2025
Hands down the best pizza and subs in Brockport. Steak subs are awesome. Staff is friendly and so are the delivery staff. Love the loyalty program every dollar spent is a dollar earned and so many options to choose from when using points.

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Angel City Pizza
(127 review)
Angel City Pizza
  • 12926 Venice Blvd., Los Angeles, CA 90066, United States
pizza restaurant
+1 310-439-2630
Cumbres Express Burger
(444 review)
Cumbres Express Burger
  • Pedregal de La Cima 4401-local 5, Pedregal Cumbres, 64344 Monterrey, N.L., Mexico
hamburger restaurant
+52 81 2347 8947
Bandoleros Tacos & Tequila Bar - Fort Lauderdale
(370 review)
Bandoleros Tacos & Tequila Bar - Fort Lauderdale
  • 208 SW 2nd St, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 786-913-9307
Chino Latino
(127 review)
Chino Latino
  • Boar Ln, Leeds LS1 5NS, United Kingdom
asian restaurant
+44 113 380 4080
El Semaforo
(920 review)
El Semaforo
  • Rio Panuco 2222, Mexico, 64740 Monterrey, N.L., Mexico
restaurant
+52 81 8387 4736
Sa-Tén @ Canopy
(779 review)
Sa-Tén @ Canopy
  • 916 Springdale Rd Bldg 3, #101, Austin, TX 78702, United States
Cafe
+1 512-524-1544
New Bremen Coffee Co. Inc.
(202 review)
New Bremen Coffee Co. Inc.
  • 115 W Monroe St, New Bremen, OH 45869, United States
Coffee shop
+1 419-629-8009
Birria Quesatacos SYR
(107 review)
Birria Quesatacos SYR
  • 415 W Onondaga St, Syracuse, NY 13202, United States
mexican restaurant
+1 315-447-3367
Touken Sushi - Hunters Creek
(891 review)
Touken Sushi - Hunters Creek
  • 12200 Menta St #106, Orlando, FL 32837, United States
Restaurant
+1 407-930-8767
Healing Springs Country Store
(275 review)
Healing Springs Country Store
  • 2563 Healing Springs Rd, Blackville, SC 29817, United States
american restaurant
+1 803-284-3377